Dr Luke Wee
November 19, 2026

We are Preventing the Wrong Death

There is an outcome we still underestimate - losing your mind before you lose your life.
Found this valuable? Share it forward.

Modern preventive medicine is remarkably good at thinking about death.

We calculate cardiovascular risk. We lower LDL. We treat blood pressure. We screen for bowel, breast, cervical and lung cancer. Increasingly, we measure coronary calcium and debate whether someone's ApoB should be 80 or 60.

All of this matters. I spend much of my working life doing it.

But there is an outcome we still underestimate - losing your mind before you lose your life.

If you offered me a choice between dying suddenly from a heart event, and spending the preceding decade progressively losing my memory, judgement, language and the ability to recognise the people I love — I know which future frightens me more.

That is an uncomfortable thing to say, so let me be careful about what I am and am not claiming.

A person living with dementia has not lost their dignity or their personhood. They remain a person, deserving exactly the same love and moral standing as anyone else. But dementia progressively erodes the capacities through which we experience and express personhood — memory, agency, recognition, and the continuity between who we were yesterday and who we understand ourselves to be today.

There is a finding from Aotearoa New Zealand that holds this distinction better than any philosophical argument. Māori researchers studying mate wareware — the te reo Māori term for dementia, the illness of forgetting — have described kaumātua returning increasingly to te reo as the condition progresses, sometimes to a first language suppressed decades earlier. The recent memory disappears while something older surfaces. The person is not reducible to what they can recall on command.

Cancer attacks the body. A myocardial infarction can stop the heart. Dementia alters the person experiencing the illness, while leaving the body alive for years afterwards. That is why families so often describe it as a succession of losses rather than a single event.

Photo by Callum Parker on Unsplash

And the losses are rarely confined to one person. Memory carries relationships. An ageing brain does not hold only one person's recollections — it may hold the history of a marriage, the childhoods of several children, stories no one thought to write down, a language, knowledge that exists nowhere else. Māori models of health have long placed whānau inside the conception of health itself. In Te Whare Tapa Whā, taha whānau — family wellbeing and belonging — is one of the four walls of health. Seen through that lens, cognition also has an intergenerational dimension.

And yet our model of prevention still gives cognitive health surprisingly little attention.

That is becoming hard to justify. Dementia overtook coronary heart disease to become Australia's leading underlying cause of death in 2024. But the more important change is conceptual.

There is a paradox here. The success of preventive medicine has created its next problem. We have become better at preventing premature death, which means more of us will live long enough to encounter the diseases of an ageing brain. The longer we succeed in preserving the body, the more important it becomes to preserve the mind that must inhabit it.

For decades, we treated dementia as something that happened to old people. Someone became forgetful, their family became concerned, and eventually we performed cognitive testing and imaging. We waited for the brain to fail before becoming interested in the brain.

Cardiovascular medicine abandoned that model half a century ago. We do not wait for your first heart attack before becoming interested in your arteries. We measure blood pressure at 40 and intervene on risk decades before the event we are trying to prevent.

Our approach to dementia is beginning the same transition. The 2024 Lancet Commission estimated that around 45% of dementia cases could potentially be prevented or delayed by addressing 14 modifiable risk factors across the life course.

That figure needs interpreting carefully. It is a population estimate, not a promise to an individual. Genetics, biology and chance remain. Prevention changes probabilities; it does not offer guarantees.

But look at the factors themselves. High LDL. Hypertension. Diabetes. Obesity. Smoking. Physical inactivity. Excess alcohol. We already know these — they are cardiovascular risk factors. The vessels supplying your heart and the vessels supplying your brain do not live in separate universes. The cardiologist and the neurologist have, to a surprising extent, been fighting the same war in different organs.

In other words, we have spent decades practising dementia prevention without calling it dementia prevention.

Then the brain adds factors of its own: hearing loss, untreated visual impairment, depression, traumatic brain injury, social isolation. It asks whether the 52-year-old who exercises diligently but has untreated hearing loss should regard that as a health issue rather than an inconvenience. Whether the socially isolated 60-year-old man carries a risk factor every bit as worthy of attention as his lipid panel. I think he does.

Photo by Robina Weermeijer on Unsplash

The brain offers one further idea, and it may be the most hopeful one: reserve. Two people can accumulate similar amounts of neuropathology and yet function very differently, and the cognitive-reserve framework attempts to explain why some brains tolerate damage better than others. Education, cognitively demanding activity and sustained cognitive and social engagement are associated with greater cognitive reserve across a lifetime.

But reserve creates a paradox. The better a brain has been at compensating, the later impairment becomes obvious.

High performance can hide decline, because the distance between exceptional and impaired is very large.

Cognitive change in a high-functioning professional rarely announces itself as failure. The surgeon still operates; the barrister still argues; the executive still runs the meeting. What shifts first is the cost of the performance: more rereading, more preparation, more reliance on notes, less comfort improvising. The first sign may not be failure at all. It may be the growing effort required to prevent it.

Usually, this is not dementia. Stress, poor sleep, depression, alcohol and simple overload are far more common explanations. But it changes the question worth asking. A brief cognitive screen asks whether you are impaired relative to other people your age. For someone who has operated well above that line all their life, the better question is whether they are changing relative to themselves — and a reassuring score against a population norm should not always end that conversation. For someone whose working life runs on judgement, memory and synthesis, that question is not abstract.

None of which means every healthy 45-year-old needs an APOE test, amyloid PET scan or the latest blood biomarker. The mistake is confusing dementia screening with dementia prevention. The prevention horizon is decades longer than the screening horizon, and the most useful dementia consultation at 45 may involve no dementia test at all. It may involve treating blood pressure, improving metabolic health, addressing hearing, exercising, and preserving the relationships that keep a mind in use.

For those wondering how dementia is actually assessed, and when testing is genuinely warranted, I have written a practical guide: https://guide.dr-wee.com/how-do-i-test-for-dementia/

And there is a resolution here worth stating plainly. We were not wrong to prevent cardiovascular death. Coronary heart disease mortality in Australia has fallen by about 85% since its peak in 1980 — one of medicine's great achievements — and for men it remains the leading cause of death even now. The heart has not stopped deserving our attention. But that very success has changed the task. More of us survive to the ages at which the ageing brain increasingly determines the quality of life that remains. The success of preventive medicine has changed what we need to prevent.

Photo by Vlad Sargu on Unsplash

We talk constantly about lifespan, and increasingly about healthspan. Perhaps we also need to think about something like brainspan — not how long the brain remains alive, but how long it continues to support the life its owner wants to lead. Because cognition is not simply another organ system to protect. The brain is what allows us to make use of everything else we preserve.

Living longer is not the whole objective. The objective is to preserve the capacities that allow someone to inhabit the extra years — to remember, to decide, to recognise, to remain connected to the people whose lives have been intertwined with theirs.

Adding ten years to someone's life is an extraordinary achievement. Helping them remain themselves for those ten years may be a greater one.

Dr Luke Wee is a GP and longevity physician. He writes about preventive medicine, uncertainty, ageing and what good medicine looks like over the long term.

First published in The Longer Consultation on LinkedIn, 17 August 2026. Cover photograph: Ivan Lapyrin on Unsplash.

Related reading