Dr Luke Wee
November 19, 2026

Sick Until Proven Innocent

If you need a doctor to tell you whether your employee is trustworthy, you may have a management problem that medicine cannot solve.
Found this valuable? Share it forward.

A man comes to see me on a Wednesday and apologises before he has sat down.

He spent Tuesday within sprinting distance of a toilet. This morning he managed to eat toast. No fever, no blood, no pain where there should not be pain. He knows he does not need a doctor. His manager needs one, because without a certificate, the leave will not be paid.

So I take a history, check he is not dehydrated, press on his abdomen, and certify him unfit for work yesterday and today. Ten minutes. He leaves relieved and faintly embarrassed to have come.

If I write that certificate the way medical defence organisations advise, it says my opinion rests on the history provided and my examination. Read that phrase slowly, because it is an admission. My examination tells me only about Wednesday. Everything I know about Tuesday, was told to me the last 10 minutes. His employer heard the same account on Tuesday morning and decided it was not good enough. Repeated to me, it became good enough.

My opinion was honest and clinically sound. But nothing about Tuesday was independently verified. A story acquired a signature.

A Story Acquires a Signature

I am not arguing that doctors have no place in questions of work. Whether a back will tolerate a 12-hour shift, or whether a surgeon's tremor is safe in theatre, is real medicine. A recovering adult who needs paperwork for a day of gastroenteritis is not.

And notice what the certificate claims - unfit for work. It does not say unfit for his work, which might be driving a bus, operating on a spine or answering email. The same illness means very different things in those three jobs, yet nothing on the form requires me to know which one he does. The document certifies a relationship between an illness and a job, and the consultation behind it examined only one of the two.

The Cost of Not Trusting People

Then consider what the arrangement costs. A person with a self-limiting illness must find an appointment, which in much of Australia and New Zealand takes days rather than hours. They leave home while possibly still infectious, sit beside the frail and the immunosuppressed, and take a consultation that might have gone to someone whose diabetes is slipping or whose mood has been sinking for months. Nobody in the transaction wanted healthcare. Healthcare was consumed anyway.

We complain endlessly about GP shortages while requiring doctors to spend part of every week certifying that adults have experienced ordinary human illnesses.

I am also an employer, so I understand the concerns. Sick leave costs money. An absence does not disappear; it lands on a colleague who turned up. Some people lie, and anyone who pretends otherwise has never rostered a team. A uniform evidence policy also protects staff, because it stops a manager's sympathies from deciding whose illness counts.

But the strongest case for the certificate is not that it proves anything. Most employers know a doctor cannot see yesterday. What the certificate supplies is friction. Booking, travelling, waiting and paying add up to a small cost, and a small cost is enough to make a casual lie on a sunny Friday more trouble than it is worth. On this view the certificate is not evidence at all. It is a deterrent, and a deterrent does not need to be true to work.

That is the best argument for the system, and it is also where the system becomes hardest to defend. A cost imposed on everyone is paid mostly by the people who were genuinely sick, while they were sick. The man faking a Friday is the one person in the waiting room who feels fine.

An organisation that designs its policies around its least trustworthy employee eventually makes everyone live as though they are that employee. And the friction is shrinking anyway. A certificate can now be obtained by telehealth from bed, so employers are relying on a deterrent that is getting weaker, and that most of them have never tested.

The real question is not whether employers deserve accountability. They do. It is whether a scarce clinical resource should be used as a speed hump against workplace dishonesty.

Defensive Management

So why does the ritual survive? Because it is useful, just not in the way anyone says.

A manager does not want to tell an employee that they are not believed. An employee does not want to describe their bowels to their manager. The certificate spares them both, and lets the employee keep their diagnosis private, which is a genuine benefit. But it does something more valuable for the manager. It creates a record. If the absence is ever questioned, the correct procedure was followed. The manager has accepted the employee's account without taking responsibility for believing it.

Doctors will recognise the pattern, because we do it too. When we order a scan that will not change medical management, so that the record shows that we have looked, we call it defensive medicine. The medical certificate is defensive management, and I am the scan.
Photo by Zulfugar Karimov on Unsplash

The Price of Trust

Trust has never meant certainty. It means accepting that you will occasionally be deceived, in exchange for not treating everyone as a suspect. No certificate removes that possibility, and no declaration will either. Every workplace already tolerates some inefficiency. What varies is how much it is prepared to spend pretending otherwise, and who pays. Those of us who employ people spend months trying to hire someone we can trust, then hand them a policy that assumes we can't.

If you need a doctor to tell you whether your employee is trustworthy, you may have a management problem that medicine cannot solve.

The fix is proportionality, not a manifesto. In Australia, the Fair Work Act asks for evidence that would satisfy a reasonable person, and the Fair Work Ombudsman lists a statutory declaration as an acceptable example, though awards and agreements can set their own rules. That is not casual self-certification. It is a formal legal statement, and making a false one is an offence. If friction is what employers want, that is friction with legal teeth, and it costs nobody an appointment.

Yet the doctor remains the reflex. For a day or two of ordinary illness, a declaration should be enough. For repeated, prolonged or patterned absence, ask for more. For safety-critical work and genuine questions of capacity, keep the doctor, because that is where the doctor is actually useful.

New Zealand has stumbled onto part of the answer. An employer there can demand proof before an illness reaches three consecutive days, but must meet the reasonable cost of getting it. That moves the bill for an unnecessary consultation rather than removing the consultation, but it states the principle with admirable bluntness. If you want a doctor to verify a routine illness, you should pay for the privilege of not believing the person you hired.

I will keep writing these certificates. The man with the toast should not lose a day's pay because I have opinions about his workplace, and I am not going to make him the test case for an argument he did not ask to join. But I notice what happens in those ten minutes, and I would like you to notice it too.

Photo by engin akyurt on Unsplash

He told his employer he was sick. The employer asked for evidence. He told me the same story, and I put my name beneath it. The employer accepted my word.

Although it was never really my word to begin with.

Dr Luke Wee is a private physician practising across Australia and New Zealand, with interests in the relationship between medicine, leadership and human behaviour.

First published in The Longer Consultation on LinkedIn, 29 October 2026. Cover photograph: Fer Troulik on Unsplash.

Related reading