Dr Luke Wee
November 19, 2026

The Door Nobody Closed

On fertility, fatherhood and what longevity is for
Found this valuable? Share it forward.

Next month, I become a father again. I have spent a good part of my career, performing vasectomies to make sure other men don't.

I have been thinking about the distance between those two facts more than I expected. The arrival has also changed how I think about longevity, which is, after all, a large part of how I earn a living. For years my interest has been in how men preserve function - cardiovascular health, cognition, muscle, sexual function, metabolic health, the capacity to keep doing work that matters. All of that still matters to me. What has changed is the direction of the question.

Virility without Posterity

A few months ago, in Beyond Optimisation, I wrote that modern male health had begun to detach its markers from the things they once represented. Muscle without physical necessity and virility performed, without the relational grounding of fertility and posterity. I want to follow that last separation further, because there is a place in medicine where it stops being a cultural observation and becomes a clinical one.

A version of the same man comes to see me regularly. He is in his early forties, fit, successful and busy. He has spent the past decade building a career, looking after his body and keeping his options open. Children were never ruled out. They simply belonged to a later stage of life - after the business stabilised, after the next role, after the relationship felt more certain. Then he and his partner decide they would like a child, and what had existed for years as a theoretical possibility becomes a practical question. Sometimes the answer is reassuring. Sometimes he discovers that biology has been keeping its own timetable, his partner's above all, but his own as well.

He is often surprised, and the surprise tells you something. At no point did he decide against children. Fatherhood was filed with all the other things that could be settled later, and later has now arrived. This is not a story of irresponsibility. Many men defer fatherhood for good reasons, some have no say in the timing, and male fertility does not vanish at a particular birthday. But there is a difference between keeping a possibility open and ever examining what it would take to realise it.

Part of what makes the deferral so easy is how well the outward signs of virility can now be maintained. A man can preserve his physique, libido and energy well into middle age, while reproductive ageing follows a less visible course. We have become better at preserving the appearance and experience of vitality, than at recognising the limits of every capacity it once represented.

The Door Unopened

The vasectomies sit on the other side of this. In The Last Fertile Day, I wrote that medicine spends most of its time keeping futures available, and that vasectomy may be the only consultation where a man arrives not to ask what is possible but to tell me what he has decided. Some of those men are fathers who know their family is complete. Others have never wanted children and are equally clear about it - fatherhood is not a debt every man owes to biology. What both groups share is that by the time they reach me, the deciding is done. The operation only records it.

However, the man who spends his lifetime keeping his options open may never subject them to the same scrutiny.

Longevity culture has taken medicine's most familiar instinct, the wish to keep futures available, and turned it into a way of living, in which a man stays strong enough, lean enough, sexually capable enough and metabolically clean enough that no door ever has to close. The irony is that he can preserve his prime so successfully that he never notices the one door it does not hold open.

The man with a vasectomy closed that door on purpose. Nobody closed the other man's door; he assumed it would stay as he had left it while he attended to other rooms. What troubles me in that comparison is not childlessness. It is drift.

When Fertility Becomes the Reason

For the man who does decide he wants a child, something different can follow - fertility stops being a test result and becomes a reason. I have watched men ignore years of advice about their weight, their drinking and their sleep, then reorganise all three within weeks of a poor semen analysis. The information had not changed. The stakes had. Losing five kilograms because your HbA1c is creeping upwards is one thing; losing them because you and the woman you love are trying to bring someone into existence is another. Medicine tends to underestimate how much a reason matters.

There is a clinical case for taking this seriously, too. Paul Turek, MD, FACS, the Californian reproductive urologist, has argued for years that male infertility can be read as a biomarker of general health. He has gone as far as calling the semen analysis "the new Pap smear for men" But a Danish study of more than 78,000 men assessed in the context of infertility found that those with the best semen quality had an estimated life expectancy around 2–3 years longer than those with severely impaired parameters. Other research has associated poor semen quality with metabolic disease, cardiovascular disease and some cancers. While these remain associations rather than direct causation, the separation between reproductive health and general male health is getting harder to defend.

Sperm take roughly three months to develop, giving changes in reproductive health a time horizon that men can understand. Smoking, obesity and metabolic dysfunction can adversely affect semen quality, although the evidence varies and improvements are not guaranteed. Yet a man who shrugs at uncertain evidence for the sake of a better biomarker, may take it seriously for the sake of a child he has not yet met. Sleep matters differently when he is not merely trying to improve an Oura score.

None of this makes sperm count a longevity score. Fertility belongs to a couple, its causes are many, and much male infertility has nothing to do with lifestyle. Biology has never distributed virtue according to semen parameters. Some men who want children will not have them; others become fathers through adoption, donor conception or step-parenthood. Others pour themselves into nieces and nephews, community, students, clients and work that outlasts them. Posterity has never been only genetic.

The Irreducible Complexity of Male Fertility

But the body has never organised itself by the departments of a longevity clinic either. Metabolism, sleep, hormones, inflammation, sexual function and reproduction are in constant conversation; we divide them because medicine needs specialties and billing codes, and physiology has never respected the filing system. A man who sets out to recover his fertility usually ends up attending to most of the above, and for a reason larger than a dashboard.

I should be honest about my part in this. Much of my working life goes on the unglamorous machinery of a longer life - blood pressure, cholesterol, insulin resistance, sleep, the muscle men quietly lose from middle age, and the sexual difficulties they leave until the last five minutes of the consultation. Almost all of it is worth doing, and certainly an improvement on the older model of male health, in which a man discovered his cardiovascular risk factors shortly before the paramedics did.

Fatherhood as a Paradox of Longevity

But it can become strangely circular. The training supports the work, the work pays for the tests, the tests reassure him that he can keep working, and somewhere in the loop, often with my help, nobody asks what the extra decade was meant to hold.

I have become more conscious of that question because there is a baby coming into my house. A child is not a longevity intervention. Children are, in most respects, catastrophically bad for optimisation. They wreck sleep, consume money, constrain travel, bring pathogens into the house with almost military efficiency and turn an uninterrupted training session into a memory. They also make certain questions much easier to answer.
Photo by DICSON on Unsplash

Fatherhood is especially confronting for men accustomed to competence. Almost everything that makes a man successful elsewhere rewards control - anticipate the problem, allocate resources, reduce variance, protect your options. Reproduction begins with an act whose outcome cannot be guaranteed and produces a person who cannot be optimised to specification. You can feed them well, read to them, teach them what you know and try not to repeat too many of your parents' mistakes, and then, with astonishing ingratitude, they become themselves.

A child narrows a life. Another person acquires a legitimate claim on your time, your money, your sleep and your geography. There are cities you will not move to and risks you will not take because someone else now exists. It is almost offensively inefficient, and there are few worse environments for performative masculinity. A child has very little interest in the version of yourself you have learned to present to the world.

It also makes the future personal in a way no survival curve can. Before children, 70 is mostly an age you hope to reach in reasonable condition. After them, it begins to acquire faces. It is the age at which a daughter rings because something has gone badly wrong and she does not know who else to call, or a son finally understands something you explained badly when he was twenty, or there are grandchildren on the floor and you discover that quadriceps strength has finally got a use.

The metrics stop being abstract. You want enough cognition to remember the family stories, enough hearing to follow the conversation at dinner, enough reserve to get on a plane when someone needs you, and enough health that your children can spend their lives on their own concerns rather than managing yours. Longevity starts to look less like defeating ageing and more like remaining available.

With a newborn, the arithmetic is hard to ignore. A child's milestones quietly measure your own. By the time he is twenty, another twenty years will have happened to my body whether I approve of the arrangement or not.

Children do not make us immortal. If anything, they make mortality harder to ignore, and they replace the fantasy of defeating time with the responsibility of inhabiting it properly.

What Are the Years For?

I still want the years, and, God willing, I will have a good number of them. I intend to keep lifting weights, checking my blood pressure and doing all the tedious things I tell other men to do, and I will go on helping the men I look after to have their years too. But a long life is not necessarily a larger one, and keeping every door open is not the same as knowing which one you mean to walk through.

The child arriving next month has made me more particular about the question beneath the years. It was never really how long a body can be kept capable. It was whether anyone had decided what it was capable for. Mine now has an answer - a wife, children, work worth doing, and a future I will help to make, but will never fully possess.

A bride and groom walking between their guests
The Gables, Malvern East on 22 November 2015

Dr Luke Wee is a private physician practising across Australia and New Zealand. He had been reflecting on fatherhood, posterity and what it means to live well.

First published in The Longer Consultation on LinkedIn, 12 October 2026. Cover photograph: Kelli McClintock on Unsplash.

Related reading