Dr Luke Wee
November 19, 2026

The Doctor Who Doesn't Know

On general practice, now that medicine is too large to know
Found this valuable? Share it forward.

"My GP didn't know anything about it."

Patients say this with disappointment, and sometimes with something closer to indignation. They have spent three weeks inside their diagnosis. They have read the trials, the forums, and the press release about the drug awaiting approval in America. They arrive with a vocabulary they did not own a month ago and discover that the doctor opposite them has not read the paper they read at midnight.

It feels like evidence of failure. Sometimes it is. But I have become less sure that knowing less is the problem.

Medicine has grown too large for any doctor to know. There are too many diseases, too many treatments, too many guidelines and subspecialties, and too much literature arriving each week for the comprehensively knowledgeable physician to remain a plausible figure. Even inside a specialty, expertise fragments. The cardiologist who spends his week on heart failure may know relatively little about inherited arrhythmias. The endocrinologist who manages diabetes all day may go months without seeing pituitary disease.

General practice has the same problem with almost none of the boundaries. In one morning, a GP can see an infant with eczema, a man with erectile dysfunction, a woman with an incidental liver lesion, a teenager who has stopped going to school, a new diagnosis of Parkinson's, and an elderly man whose daughter no longer thinks he is safe to drive. The mythology of the profession has always been comprehensiveness. We were meant to know a little about everything, and the difficulty is that everything has become rather large.

The two people in the room also experience an asymmetry differently. To the person who has it, the condition is the most important disease in medicine. They have read about it because it has turned their life upside down. They know the drug names because they take them every morning, and they know the order in which the symptoms arrived because they were there. To the GP it is one condition among several hundred. Someone who has read everything about one of them will sometimes, know more about it than their doctor does.

So doctors should become more comfortable saying "I don't know."

One Sentence, Many Meanings

But "I don't know" is not one sentence. It is at least three, and in a ten-minute consultation they can sound identical.

"I don't know, but I can find out" is curiosity. "I don't know enough to advise you properly, and here is who does" is judgment. "I don't know, and I would rather not" is abdication, and it is usually spoken as a referral. That is what makes it hard to see.

A referral can carry any of the three. The same letter to the same specialist can come from a doctor who has recognised the edge of their competence, or from one who simply wants to get the problem out of their room. The patient holding the letter rarely knows which one is it.

General practice has answered the growth of medicine partly by narrowing, and it could hardly have done otherwise. Nobody maintains procedural skill, obstetrics, paediatrics, complex mental health, dermatology, musculoskeletal medicine, aged care and sexual medicine at equal depth across a 40-year career. Most GPs become better at some things and quietly stop doing others. Some give up procedures. Some stop seeing pregnancy. Some build real expertise in addiction, skin cancer, women's health or sports medicine, or build a practice around a single population.

I have narrowed my own work as well. There are parts of the old repertoire I no longer practise. So the distinction I am about to draw is one I have had to apply to myself first.

Narrowing is fine, provided it is chosen. Narrowing says, "I cannot stay excellent at everything, so I will decide where to keep depth". Deskilling says, "I will gradually stop doing whatever is difficult". From outside or inside, they look much the same.

Photo by Brett Jordan on Unsplash

There is a third way a practice narrows, and it worries me most because nobody chooses it. A doctor who has never decided where to keep depth can end up narrowing by choosing patient rather than by choosing the field.

The unfamiliar patient becomes complex. The informed patient becomes difficult. The symptom that fits no pattern becomes psychosomatic before anyone has properly explored it, and anything that needs more time than the appointment allows is sent somewhere else. That doctor has not narrowed their competence. They have narrowed the people they are willing to keep.

This is more dangerous than admitting ignorance, because it rarely looks like ignorance. It looks like certainty. The problem is compressed until it fits the capability available to manage it. Fatigue always becomes iron studies, low libido always becomes a testosterone level, chest discomfort always leads to a stress test, and distress always becomes depression.

Sometimes compression is exactly what good medicine requires. Pattern recognition is indispensable. Most headaches are not tumours, most palpitations are not a dangerous rhythm, and no health system can investigate every possibility to exhaustion. Simplification becomes a problem only when it stops being a way of thinking and becomes a way of not having to. The patient usually notices before the doctor does.

The Modern Generalist Will Never Know Enough

This is why I think the old promise of general practice needs rewriting. The modern generalist is not the doctor who knows enough about everything. It is the doctor who knows where their knowledge ends and does not let their responsibility end in the same place.

That is a different kind of expertise, and a harder one to demonstrate. It means being able to admit ignorance, without losing the patient's confidence. It means knowing which part of a problem you can manage, which part needs someone better than you, and knowing enough to recognise that someone when you meet them. And it means taking the patient back afterwards.

A referral should transfer a question, not the patient. The neurologist answers the neurological question. The surgeon decides whether something can be cut out. The psychologist reaches a part of the story none of the doctors could. But someone still has to notice when the neurologist's medication has pushed up the blood pressure, or the cardiologist's advice contradicts the nephrologist's. Someone has to see that the operation under discussion fixes an anatomical problem the patient is not much troubled by, or that five correct specialist opinions do not add up to a sensible life. The GP need not hold every relevant fact. But once knowledge has been divided among many people, someone has to remain answerable for the whole.

This changes the bargain between doctor and patient, and the patient's side of it is uncomfortable to state. Patients may need to allow their doctors to be incomplete. Your GP may look something up in front of you, reread the letter, or fail to recognise the syndrome you have spent a fortnight researching. They may ring a colleague or tell you plainly that you now know more than they do. None of this should automatically cost them your confidence.

Humility is Not Inadequacy

The latitude has to be earned, though, and the profession's side of the bargain is less comfortable still. Incomplete knowledge can only be reassuring, if the patient believes there is more capability behind it, when they have seen what the doctor can do inside their limits. Humility without competence is not humility. It is inadequacy described attractively.

This is the part of the conversation about scope that I think the profession avoids. We argue, correctly, that the GP cannot do everything. We speak of teams, pathways, multidisciplinary care and appropriate scope, and all of it is true. But a profession that keeps defining what it no longer does will eventually struggle to explain what it is for. Suppose every difficult psychiatric presentation goes to psychiatry, every sore back to physiotherapy, every mole to dermatology, every reproductive question to women's health, every complicated metabolic patient to endocrinology, and every uncertain presentation to the emergency department. What is left that requires the doctor with the broadest training in the system?

A profession can build the case for its own substitution one sensible exclusion at a time.

The Work Is Changing

That case gets easier to make every year. Much of the informational work of general practice is now available elsewhere. Patients read the guidelines, pharmacists manage defined medication problems, nurses run protocolised chronic-disease programmes, and AI will answer a growing share of the questions that once needed an appointment. Whatever is defensible about general practice, it cannot be that we possess basic medical information. It has to be what we can do when the information does not fit. That means three things wrong at once, or a guideline for one disease that worsens another. It means a normal test in a patient who plainly is not well, or a request for something technically available that may not be wise. It means a problem no specialist owns, or one that is medical, psychological, relational and social at once, as human problems inconveniently tend to be.

That work requires breadth, even if it no longer requires omniscience. The doctor who personally performs every part of care is disappearing, probably for good. But the doctor who remains has to know enough cardiology to argue sensibly with the cardiologist, enough psychiatry to recognise when distress is more than distress, and enough pharmacology to see the interaction coming. They need enough general medicine to notice when the story does not fit, and enough about the person to judge whether the technically correct answer is the right one for them.

They do not need to know everything. They must possess the desire to know.

I have come to think curiosity is among the most important clinical competencies, precisely because it survives the limits of knowledge. A curious doctor can discover what they do not know. An incurious one can carry an enormous amount of knowledge and still become unsafe the moment the patient steps outside it. The patient who arrives with three weeks of reading material is not really asking whether their GP has read the same paper. They are asking whether the doctor will read it now, and whether if doctor begins the work or discharges the work prematurely.

Photo by Gary Butterfield on Unsplash

Medicine has outgrown the omniscient doctor, and general practice should say so. We may need to give GPs permission to know less. I am less convinced we should give ourselves permission to become capable of less.

Dr Luke Wee is a general practitioner and private physician working across Australia and New Zealand. He writes about medicine and the parts of care that resist easy measurement or scale.

First published in The Longer Consultation on LinkedIn, 29 September 2026. Cover photograph: Nappy on Unsplash.

Related reading