
How to Choose a Doctor (You Can't)
A man in his forties decides it is time to finally find a proper GP. Something has prompted it. His father has had a scare, his left knee has started making a noise like a pepper grinder, or he has worked out that the last time anyone took his blood pressure he was thirty-one.
So he does what anyone does now. He opens twelve browser tabs.
What he finds is a distinct and slightly airless literary genre. A photograph of a man standing against a white wall. A line on where the doctor trained. A list of special interests — skin, chronic disease, mental health, travel medicine, sports injuries. Sometimes a list of publications. Sometimes a year of graduation, on which the reader quietly does mental arithmetic to establish that the doctor is old enough to be wise and young enough not to drop dead mid-consult.
Then, near the bottom, the inevitable sentence about the labrador and the social tennis.
He reads all twelve and closes the laptop knowing absolutely nothing.
The Illusion of the Résumé
It is worth being clear that none of it is padding. The training is real and hard-won. A publication means someone read the literature closely enough to argue with it. A special interest means genuine extra hours, usually unpaid, usually at night.
The awkward fact is only that the same page — same university, same fellowship, same three papers — sits above a doctor you would trust with your father, and above one who will make you feel like the fourth item on a morning list.
Every item on that list is a record of something the doctor has acquired. What the man wants to know is what the doctor does in a room.
The headshot, my personal Waterloo
Then there is the photograph, about which I have no standing to be superior at all.

The tie is the first decision and it is a trap in both directions. With one you look like a man about to discuss your insurance needs; without one you have made a bid for approachability that the open collar then announces aggressively on your behalf. Scrubs settle it instantly and photograph beautifully, which is why they are everywhere, despite many of us never having worn them anywhere near an operating theatre. I wear them in mine because they suggest I might be called away for an emergency appendicectomy, rather than what I am actually doing, which is running fifteen minutes late because I could not work out the printer.
Then comes the expression, where the only usable option is the slight smile, which cannot be produced deliberately. Hold it past a second and it becomes a grimace of mild discomfort, and naturally that is the exact frame that gets taken.
Here is the deflating part. Men have told me, more than once and without a shred of embarrassment, that they booked because they swiped right to the photograph. Not the training. Not the writing. The photograph — the only item on the entire page that makes no claim about anything.
I could not tell you what quality my slightly pained half-smile appeared to convey, and I certainly could not produce that quality on request in a consulting room. Whatever they saw, they had not seen me do a single thing. They had seen a middle-aged man hold his face still for a fraction of a second, some months earlier, in reasonable light.
The Labrador Paragraph
The paragraph about the labrador is the profession's one clumsy attempt to say the missing thing directly, and I have some sympathy for it. Somebody understood that everything above it described attainment rather than manner, and tried to correct the balance.
But warmth does not survive being asserted.

A man reading Dr Wee enjoys hiking, coffee and spending time with his family learns only that someone tried to compress a human being into fifteen bland words. The quality he is trying to detect is the one quality that cannot be advertised, and the attempt to advertise it is only evidence of how hard it is to convey.
What is Never on the Page
Consider what actually determines his experience of a doctor over the next ten years. Whether the man asks why he really came in, rather than treating the presenting complaint at face value. Whether he will say I don't know and mean it as the beginning of something, rather than an apology or defense. Whether he will tell him a test is not worth doing, or a treatment is not appropriate, and hold that position when pressed. Whether he will still remember, in eighteen months, what was said about the marriage. Whether he can delicately hold three problems at once even when the appointment was booked for one.
Not one of those is provable in advance. That is precisely why the other things get listed. They are the legible part.
Which means the search, as it is normally conducted, cannot work. A man could read every GP profile in the eastern suburbs and be no better placed than when he started. The frustration he feels is not a sign that he is bad at this. It is a sign that he has been asked to make a judgement without the material a judgement requires.
Inside the Room
The recognition, when it comes, comes from inside the room. Many men know earlier than they expect to, well before any clinical question has been settled. It arrives through small things that are impossible to put on a website and unmistakable when they happen. A question that goes one layer past the presenting complaint, a pause that is not being managed, a willingness to say that something is not necessary. He is not assessing the doctor's competence in those minutes - he almost certainly cannot. He is registering whether he is being taken seriously, which turns out to be the thing he actually came for.

For the man who has not found this yet, I wish I could say something more useful than keep looking, because in much of Australia and New Zealand - looking is not the easy part. Books are closed. Waits are long. Continuity is hard to build when you cannot reliably see the same person twice. Whatever is going on here, it is not a failure of his judgement, and it is not evidence that the quality of care is not good. Most consultations are considerably decent, and he will be in safe hands.
But there is one thing I would say to the much larger group - the men who already have a GP, have had one for many years, and yet have never once truly discover who they have actually got.
He goes in for the script and the referral. Ten minutes, in and out. The relationship never gets tested because nothing is ever asked of it. He has no idea whether the doctor he already has, is the doctor he is looking for, because he has never given him a question worth answering.
At the next appointment, try one. Skip the sore shoulder. The thing you have been meaning to mention for two years and take back out of the room with you each time — the drinking, the sleep, the anxiety, the father, the fact that you do not feel like yourself and have not for a while. Say it in the first minute rather than the last.
Then watch what the doctor does.
Dr Luke Wee is a specialist General Practitioner based in the eastern suburbs of Melbourne. He writes about the enduring value of the physician relationship.
First published in The Longer Consultation on LinkedIn, 7 August 2026. Cover photograph: the National Cancer Institute on Unsplash.