Dr Luke Wee
November 19, 2026

The Treatment Worked

On success, depression and the limits of what medicine can fix
Found this valuable? Share it forward.

He could not explain why he was unhappy, and that seemed to trouble him more than the unhappiness itself. There was no catastrophe to point to. His marriage was intact and his children were well. The business had grown into the thing he once described to investors as though it were already true, and money had stopped being a source of anxiety years earlier. He trained most mornings, travelled, had friends he genuinely liked, and lived in a house that had once looked, from a distance, like proof that life had worked out. By any measure he could have shown to someone else, it had.

What he described was a tiredness that sleep no longer corrected. His concentration had slipped. He was short with the people he loved and noticed it afterwards, which was worse. He looked forward to weekends and then did not know what to do inside them. Sex had become something he remembered enjoying rather than something he wanted. He was not sure whether he was depressed. Mostly, he wanted his testosterone checked.

That was not an unreasonable request, and I did not treat it as one. Low testosterone produces some of this picture. So do thyroid disease, anaemia, sleep apnoea, alcohol, medication, and the slow metabolic drift of a man in his late 40s who sits for 11 hours a day. There is a particular laziness in telling a tired, flat and disengaged man that he is simply stressed, and it is practised most confidently on men whose lives look too comfortable to deserve a diagnosis. Successful people are not exempt from illness because their lives photograph well.

So we investigated, and medicine found enough to get its hands around. His testosterone was a little low. It was not dramatically low, but it was low enough to repeat and to ask why. He had gained weight around his middle without quite noticing. His sleep was poor, and he was drinking more than he had first said. When I told him, he seemed almost relieved, and I understood it.

A number turns a diffuse unhappiness into an object that can be repeated, graphed and treated, and a man who has spent a year wondering why he cannot pull himself together. He can feel something close to forgiveness, when a pathology report gives the experience a name. I have written elsewhere about what that relief can quietly excuse. Here it was simply legitimate. The result was real, and so was the sleep, and so was the drinking.

Over the following appointments we talked about other things, as you do when you see someone often enough for the conversation to wander. He still loved parts of his work, though most of those parts had disappeared as the company grew. The work he used to do had become meetings about the people who now did it, and his calendar had been cut into pieces small enough that nothing in it was difficult and all of it was exhausting. He was usually gone before his children woke.

In the evenings he was present in the technical sense, answering email while his youngest told him about her day. He told himself it was temporary, as he had been telling himself for six years. He and his wife were not unhappy, exactly. They ran the household well together. There was affection and history. He drank because it marked the end of the working day, except that the working day had stopped ending.

Photo by Anastasia Zhenina on Unsplash

I noticed all of it and said very little, and that was deliberate. None of it meant he was not depressed. I am wary of the fashionable habit of reading every depressive illness as a meaningful protest against modern life. Sometimes the brain is simply unwell, medication helps enormously, and the man with everything to live for genuinely cannot feel that it is true. Nor did I think a doctor who had met him four times had earned a view on his marriage or his company. A medical degree contains remarkably little training in how another person ought to live, and there is something faintly absurd about a physician informing a man he barely knows that the answer to his life is better boundaries. So I treated what was in front of me.

And the treatment worked. His sleep improved first, then his energy. He cut back his drinking and lost a few kilograms. The repeat testosterone came back better than the first. For a few months the story resolved itself into something satisfyingly medical, the kind of case you would be comfortable presenting at a meeting: each abnormal result followed by a better one, each intervention earning its place.

At what should have been a routine review, he told me he felt better, and he meant it. He had his jacket on and was halfway out of the chair when he stopped, in the way patients do when the real reason for the visit has been waiting until there is no time left to discuss it.

I just thought I would want my life more than I truly do.

It was the first thing he had said in four months that did not sound like a symptom.

He sat back down. For a while I said nothing, partly because I had nothing useful to say and partly because the silence seemed to belong to him. Then I asked the question that opens almost every history I have ever taken. It is the question I ask about a cough, a chest pain or a numb left hand, and I had never before thought to ask it about a life.

When did it start?

He took a long time to answer. It was longer than he had taken over anything else I had asked him.

I have thought about his sentence often since, because I think it describes something particular to the men who say it. When you are young, dissatisfaction has somewhere to go. It can be assigned to what you do not yet have: the job, the money, the title, the house, the person you hope will love you, the children you hope to have. The future holds enormous explanatory power, because almost everything important is still somewhere ahead. Then, for some men, most of it arrives. It never arrives perfectly, but it arrives sufficiently, and the explanations leave with it.

If you have spent 20 years believing life will feel different once you get there, it is a frightening thing to arrive and feel the same. Success does not cause that unhappiness. It removes the alibi. I recognise the sentence, as I suspect most doctors of my age would if they were honest. We are largely the same people, just with better access to our own blood results.
Photo by Borna Hržina on Unsplash

This is one of the places where medicine can quietly lose its way. We worry, rightly, about missing disease in the man whose life looks fine. We worry far less about what happens after we have found the disease, treated it properly, and something remains. What remains looks exactly like the original complaint. He is still flat. He still does not want much. Faced with a symptom that persists after treatment, the medical reflex is to treat harder. We push his body harder than what his body needs.

We beat the body with more exercise, trying to make it leaner and stronger, with the hope that an improved biomarker might make the man happier. We start an antidepressant for a depression the history does not quite describe. We wonder aloud about attention and whether a stimulant might help him focus. Each step is defensible on its own. Together they become a doctor answering a question about a life with a prescription for a body. And the patient keeps accepting the prescriptions, because a problem with the body is still easier to contemplate, than a problem not of the body.

I can prescribe more treatments. I can arrange a sleep study, talk to him about alcohol, and take seriously the 10kg kilograms he acquired without noticing. These are medical problems and they deserve medical care. What I cannot prescribe is a Wednesday afternoon with his daughter. There is no script for the conversations he and his wife stopped having somewhere between the second child and the third capital raise. There is no MBS item number for work that still feels worth doing once nobody is applauding. No request form will tell me whether the life he spent 20 years building still resembles the one he meant to build.

Photo by Limor Zellermayer on Unsplash

He did answer, eventually. I will not repeat what he said; the question ultimately belongs to him, and it was not a diagnosis. What stays with me is the order in which things happened. He came wanting to know why he was tired. Medicine found real reasons and dealt with most of them, and only once the tiredness had lifted, could he hear what it was underneath. The treatment had not failed. It had done just enough to leave him alone with the question it could not answer.

At the end of the appointment, I wrote the request for his repeat bloods in three months, as I would have anyway. It was the only part of the consultation that came with a form.

Dr Luke Wee is a private physician and general practitioner. He writes about men’s health, preventive medicine, and the limits of what medicine can solve.

First published in The Longer Consultation on LinkedIn, 6 October 2026. Cover photograph: Helen Cramer on Unsplash.

Related reading